Finders Keepers. Critics Consensus. I doubt I'll enjoy any movie I see in the rest of 2015 as much as Finders Keepers. October 11, 2017 Full. Directed by Alexander Yellen. With Jaime Pressly, Patrick Muldoon, Tobin Bell, Marina Sirtis. A divorced mother of one is thrown into turmoil when her young daughter becomes obsessed with an evil doll left behind by the previous occupants of their new home.